PM WANI Scheme: A Critical Look at this Internet Game Changer



The PM WANI Scheme has taken India by storm. The government has intended to be an internet game-changer in the country. By turning every shop into an internet hotspot and every region in a Public Data Office, it’s a move that can put India on part with western countries. However, is that really the case? Can this move truly be successful, or, it will make India’s already dubious cybersecurity, more vulnerable? Let’s take a look at this critical game-changer. 

 On December 14, 2020, the government of India made a momentous decision that, similar to all the decisions that the current regimen has made, drew the attention of media like never before – the introduction of the PM Wi-Fi Access Network Interface or the PM WANI Scheme.

 The mission of this scheme: Elevating the framework for wireless connectivity across the country. It entails the development of a framework that through the following elements, would put India on the world’s internet map:

 

  1. Public Data Office (PDOs)
  2. Public Data Office Aggregators, and
  3. App providers.

 Hailed by the Communication’s Minister Mr. Ravi Shankar Prasad as a No license and No registration scheme, it’s a move to turn everything from small shops to common service centers to PDOs so that people can have internet access, wherever they go.

 

PM WANI Scheme: What is it

The core of this scheme is to provide internet access to people using Public Data Officers. Primarily aimed at “Ease of Doing Business”, the PM WANI project’s secondary objective is to promote “ease of living” in modern India.

 

How does this scheme work?

The scheme aims to facilitate internet connectivity throughout the country by doing the following:

  1. Establish Public Data Office Aggregators: A body that will provide internet services through specialized units known as a Public data office.
  2. Public Data Office: Public Data Office are shops, common service centers, and other stores that can connect with an internet service provider to establish internet hotspots at their premises.
  3. App provider: The Government of India will provide an app allowing the user to find a public data office within the vicinity. Once the app finds a PDO, the user will authenticate himself, pay the requisite fees to the PDO and get a Wi-Fi password to connect to the internet.

 

Is this India’s first attempt to provide Wi-Fi access to travelers?

No. Before the PM WANI Yojana, providing wireless internet access by establishing hotspots was an idea implemented by both Google and Facebook. 

 

Google partnered with Railtel to provide free Wi-Fi services on railway stations across the globe. The plan began in 2015. Eventually, it expanded to 400 railway stations. Furthermore, within a short amount of time, it had nearly 2.6 Crore users per month and aggregated data exceeding 9,490 terabytes. However, it shut down in early 2020.

Facebook on the other hand went with a profit-centric approach towards providing Wi-Fi access in open regions. Implementing the motto of “building, operating, growing and monetizing Wi-Fi business”, the social media giant introduced Express Wi-Fi for mobile network operators and internet service providers. Unlike Google, which endeavored to provide internet services for free, Facebook decided to sell vouchers worth rupees INR 20 a day to INR 300 a month to render internet services. But, it met the same fate as Google’s WiFi and got shut down the same year.

 

Why did these attempts fail?

Needless to say, Facebook and Google’s attempt to provide internet access could’ve proven far more effective than the PM WANI Scheme, if implemented properly. However, they never came to pass. As for the reasons behind their sudden abandonment, they are:

 

  1. A drastic change in the internet market: Google and RaiTel’s joint venture couldn’t lead to fruition in India, and the world due to a drastic change in the internet market. As per the blog post by Ceasar Sengupta, VP – Payments and Next Billion Users, Google, Internet connection on railway stations has outlived its relevance. Sengupta said – “With mobile data plans becoming more affordable, and the mobile networks becoming more consolidated, there is no need for Wi-Fi connectivity exclusively for the railway stations.”

 

  1. The reason behind shut down of Express Wi-Fi: Citing the same reasons as Google, Facebook took the same route and shut down. However, the real reason behind this move might have been more insidious than meets the eye. With India becoming self-reliant and creating an environment conducive for the growth of domestic industries, Facebook might have thought the country's national interest might not align with its foreign ones. As a result, it decided to rather hedge its bets on other countries rather than stay in the country that has Wi-Fi plans of its own.

 

Analyzing the technical details of the above initiatives and the PM WANI Scheme – similarities can be found. They range from objectives as well as challenges. Both those schemes succumbed to the competition by India’s Data plans. PM WANI scheme will likely face the same challenge and might find it equally difficult to counter.

 

But there are other challenges too that the Indian government must not ignore if it wants this scheme to truly be a game-Changer.

 

 Challenges of PM WANI Scheme

Internet access has always posed the question about inquisitive freedom – questions that a person is allowed to ask, stuff that he or she is allowed to search. Therefore, it’s important that the titular scheme goes ahead keeping the following challenges in mind:

 

1.      Vulnerabilities of Open Wi-Fi: While Open Wi-Fi can be quite convenient for people, that comfort comes with a trade-off – that of personal security. People and the government know that open networks are often vulnerable to hacks and breaches. Currently, India ranks 10th in the world’s cybersecurity index. However, that position can go down if it doesn’t take heed of the vulnerabilities that come with an open network that can be accessed by anyone with a password and authentication.

2.      Absence of robust data protection legislation: The data protection act has been introduced. However, it has yet to fully become an act. Thus, it stands now as nothing more than a theory. In the absence of an implementable data protection legislation, current Public Data Offices are left with ambiguous guidelines known to have been misused in the past to steal public information.

3.      Storing data for more than a year: One of the prominent guidelines of the scheme state that the public data office can retain the personal information of the user for one year. By merely existing, this guideline violates a person’s “Right to be forgotten”. While not an absolute right, it has to be taken into consideration, especially if the latest rendition of the Personal Data Protection Bill has stated that the Right to be Forgotten is a Fundamental right of a citizen.

4.      People’s tiredness with authentication: Mobile data plans are now more ubiquitous than ever. People who are using them have no incentive to switch to a public data plan that forces them to authenticate themselves – a move that has increasingly lost its popularity because of the constant inconvenience it has caused.

5.      Low internet awareness in marginalized areas: Despite what the news channels say, the fact remains that there are still remote regions where people can’t even spell “Internet”. As such, the chances that the benefits of these benefits will reach the remote areas are significantly low.

6.      Presence of Low-cost mobile data plans: Low-cost mobile data plans have risen in the market, and so are their takers. Therefore, the scheme can only prove fruitful if it has some sort of incentive internet users can take that they can’t with the affordable data plans.

 

While the weight of the aforementioned challenges is significant, the government can fix them if it heeds to the solutions.

 

Fixing the Scheme to make it more In-line with India’s internet requirement

Aligning the scheme with what India needs, instead of what it wants can fix the challenges of this game-changing internet scheme:

 

1.      Consolidating user data protection on an open network: Countries like the USA have already implemented several measures that have created a robust firewall to ensure that the personal data of the users who are accessing an open Wi-Fi network remains safe. Those measures are affordable and with India’s high-ranking Cyber-security index, it’s safe to assume that they are implementable.

2.      Increasing the efforts of the government: The Government of India should set up a fund to deploy this scheme in marginalized regions. It can set up a high-level committee that will conduct a high-level survey of the remote regions of the country. The committee can then direct the funds based on the internet awareness of those regions.

3.      Incentivising the mobile data users: Considering that only traveling internet users are the only ones to benefit from this scheme, the government has to introduce measures to incentivize them.

 

The Scheme is Indeed a game Changer But

The PM WANI Scheme is indeed a game-changer, however, it’s not so to the degree as the media is advertising. For it to be so, the government must take note of the current challenges and must implement solutions that can promote “ease of living” for the people of India. However, it can only happen if people are aware of the present internet solutions present to them.

Thus, it’s safe to assume that the current appearance of this move’s game-changing aspect is at an intermediate stage. Currently, the best we can do is observe and see what kind of shape this move makes.

0 Comments